|
by Franziska Zellweger, University of St. Gallen
Rather than summarizing the current state Martin Trow tries to
conceptualize actual developments in higher education issued by
information and communication technology (ICT). In order to do
so, he has chosen a language, that is close to the empirical reality
and maintains value in the nearer future although actual technology
may be obsolete already tomorrow.
If anybody, Martin Trow is the person to put actual developments
in perspective. As a scholar of public policy he has worked in
the field for more than 50 years, he headed the Center for Studies
in Higher Education at Berkeley in the 70ies and 80ies and has
contributed to the discussion ever since.
In the first section of the paper Trow identifies five stable
characteristics, which shape how any technological innovation affects
the form and process of higher education in any advanced society.
They are
- the speed of technological change,
- the tendency
of ICT’s to weaken and blur institutional and intellectual
boundaries of all kinds;
- the democratizing effect through the
expansion of access and the leveling of the status of institutions;
- the varying impact of ICT on different academic subjects;
- and the different ways students use the new opportunities.
These characteristics suggest that developments in ICT cannot
be treated as a single phenomenon. One has to specify what
and where they are being used, for what and by whom to analyze
its
impact on higher education. In his further explanations Trow focuses on some of the main issues
discussed in higher education studies such as the growing demand
for continuing education and the role of ICT, the way how distance
learning will be integrated in traditional institutions and how
it changes the nature of the work in these institutions. Finally
he focuses on the normative debate on the basic educational functions
of higher education (liberal and professional education) and how
it is affected by ICT.
Trow’s evaluation of the influence of ICT on the higher
education system is of a surprisingly optimistic nature in contrast
to the many depictions that fear the worst for the basic academic
values. He doesn’t expect the dissolution of traditional
academia but envisions a combination of traditional and distance
learning.
In a way he ignores the concrete impact the macro developments
have on the individual university campus. In particular the alarming
financial impact of growing student enrollments and the costly
sustenance of an ICT infrastructure remain unmentioned. But by
ignoring the current “micro” issues he manages to clarify
the big picture and provides a language to discuss the impact of
ICT on higher education, which is considered three years after
its creation of value enough to be reviewed.
RELATED LINKS
http://www.elearning-reviews.org
FOR MORE INFO CONTACT
Jasmina Hasanbegovic
eMail: franziska.zellweger@unisg.ch
back |